An open letter to NBC and Donald Trump
I have been watching this fiasco unfold about Carrie Prejean. I can not believe the retaliation that this poor girl is made to suffer. A judge that called her answer "polarizing". Pageant directors who tried to humiliate her with news (true or false) of a breast enhancement that she denies. Statements from those same pageant directors about her opportunism. All this because she gave an honest answer to a question from a judge with an agenda.
What were the pageant officials thinking when they invited a militant homosexual with his own agenda to judge this disaster. Mario Lavendiera is a man on a mission. His biggest claim to fame is a website where he draws mustaches and cocaine on pictures of celebrities. This is a man who's command of the english language is so deep and so broad that the best insult he could come up with is to call her a f***ing b*tch. His assesment of poor Miley Cyrus is "sl*t" I'm less then impressed with who you chose to select the ultimate girl next door. That's what this competition is supposed to be about, the perfect girl next door who wants the American dream, home, family, career, isn't it.
Your own pageant directors are quoted on MSNBC as saying she forgot her commitment to the people of California. Lets look at that one shall we. Its the people of California who voted to ban gay marriage by saying yes to proposition 8. Tell me exactly how she would be representing the people of California by denying her religious beliefs and speaking out in favor of the minority. Shanna Moakler and Keith Lewis should be released from their duties ASAP because they have an agenda to humiliate her and make her suffer because she wouldn't speak the party line.
Moakler and Lewis state she has gone beyond her right to her opinion and shown her oportunistic agenda. It wasn't Prejean who started this whole thing, it was the Miss USA pageant officials and its owners for not thinking that a man like Lavendiera with a very known and public agenda wouldn't use time on national television to his own advantage and for that agenda. He openly said he took points from her not because she was inarticulate, but because she gave the wrong answer.
In the 40's when someone wouldn't speak the party line we called it the holocaust. In the 80 when it was the few telling the majority how live, we called it apartied. What do you want to call this? I call it discusting. Perhaps its time to fold the pageants. Since the owners and directors of the Miss USA pageant and its source (state) pageants have blurred the lines between current events and political activism, maybe we should be rethinking what we want from our young girls. Mr Trump, would you have wanted Ivanka to forsake the values you taught her for some silly prize? Why let your staff punish Prejean for not giving up on hers? And for the record I did support the concept of gay civil unions. I'm rethinking that now
Sunday, April 26, 2009
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Political correctness and beauty pageants
I guess its time for another rant. This time its Carrie Prejean.
What was The Donald thinking when he ok'd Perez Hilton as a judge for his Miss USA pagent? Hilton is a militant homosexual on a mission and to think he wouldn't use this platform for his agenda is silly. This is a guy who is famous for calling celebrities names and making life hell for them as well. His claim to fame is photoshopping photo's with imaginary cocaine and mustaches. I am told that after the show, in an interview, he called her answer polarizing. What kind of an answer did he expect to get from a polarizing question?
An AP story on CNN.com or MSNBC.com quotes him as saying she is supposed to represent ALL Americans. First off, how is she supposed to represent me? I'm a 51 year old married male. I've been married for 21 years. I lost interest in beauty pagents years ago. What she is supposed to represent is the perfect girl next door. She is supposed to be the good girl who studies and wants the American dream (husband, family, home etc). Exactly what does Mario know about women other then he wants to be one and wants everyone to accept him as one? He is not and even if he has a sex change, he still has that nasty Y chromasome. Sorry big guy. This is a man who rode Lance Bass and Reichen Lemkuhl so much that they finally broke up. His public comment after the break up was that now Reichen couldn't ride Lance's coattails. Um, I'm guessing that Paris Hilton must be thrilled that Mario is trying to ride hers.
The problem I have with the whole gay acceptance thing is not the lifestyle. Its that they want to legislate religion. The term marriage is a religious one. The gay community wants a law saying that a union between 2 homosexual partners should be called a marriage. The concept of a union between 2 same-sex partners bothers me because it goes against religous law, laws of nature and laws of science. In England, they have that law but to make it work, they don't call it a marriage, they call it a civil union and I'm ok with that.
Now I'm reading that Keith Lewis, co-director of the Miss California competition told FOXNews.com that he was "saddened" by Prejean's statement. Hey Donald, I'm thinking that Keith and Shanna Moakler should be looking for other work right now. Your folks who are openly stating that Prejean was wrong, (Lewis and Shanna Moakler) should be released from their duties. The idea that these 2 believe her answer was hurtful because she relied on her religious upbringing have no business working your competition.
A quote from the Fox article (http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,517215,00.html)
Charmaine Koonce, the mother of Miss New Mexico USA Bianca Matamoros-Koonce, argued back. "In the Bible it says marriage is between Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve!"
God bless mothers. Its time to get political correctness out of America.
What was The Donald thinking when he ok'd Perez Hilton as a judge for his Miss USA pagent? Hilton is a militant homosexual on a mission and to think he wouldn't use this platform for his agenda is silly. This is a guy who is famous for calling celebrities names and making life hell for them as well. His claim to fame is photoshopping photo's with imaginary cocaine and mustaches. I am told that after the show, in an interview, he called her answer polarizing. What kind of an answer did he expect to get from a polarizing question?
An AP story on CNN.com or MSNBC.com quotes him as saying she is supposed to represent ALL Americans. First off, how is she supposed to represent me? I'm a 51 year old married male. I've been married for 21 years. I lost interest in beauty pagents years ago. What she is supposed to represent is the perfect girl next door. She is supposed to be the good girl who studies and wants the American dream (husband, family, home etc). Exactly what does Mario know about women other then he wants to be one and wants everyone to accept him as one? He is not and even if he has a sex change, he still has that nasty Y chromasome. Sorry big guy. This is a man who rode Lance Bass and Reichen Lemkuhl so much that they finally broke up. His public comment after the break up was that now Reichen couldn't ride Lance's coattails. Um, I'm guessing that Paris Hilton must be thrilled that Mario is trying to ride hers.
The problem I have with the whole gay acceptance thing is not the lifestyle. Its that they want to legislate religion. The term marriage is a religious one. The gay community wants a law saying that a union between 2 homosexual partners should be called a marriage. The concept of a union between 2 same-sex partners bothers me because it goes against religous law, laws of nature and laws of science. In England, they have that law but to make it work, they don't call it a marriage, they call it a civil union and I'm ok with that.
Now I'm reading that Keith Lewis, co-director of the Miss California competition told FOXNews.com that he was "saddened" by Prejean's statement. Hey Donald, I'm thinking that Keith and Shanna Moakler should be looking for other work right now. Your folks who are openly stating that Prejean was wrong, (Lewis and Shanna Moakler) should be released from their duties. The idea that these 2 believe her answer was hurtful because she relied on her religious upbringing have no business working your competition.
A quote from the Fox article (http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,517215,00.html)
Charmaine Koonce, the mother of Miss New Mexico USA Bianca Matamoros-Koonce, argued back. "In the Bible it says marriage is between Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve!"
God bless mothers. Its time to get political correctness out of America.
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
Palin, The Election and Justice
It's time for another rant. I don't trust anybody on either side of the aisle on Capitol Hill, however the Republican choice for this years presidential contest is just crazy to me. In her acceptance speech at the RNC, Sarah Palin says she has her share of troubles like everybody else. This may be true, but "everybody else" isn't trying to convince the American public that they are the best VP choice going.
I have never been accepting of the Hollywood stars that don't need a husband to have a baby. This is wrong. I understand that accidents happen, but in this day and age, the number should be very small. The idea we are sending a just-approaching-middle-age grandmother of an illigitimate kid to Washington just shuts me down. She wants the world to know that she is ready to look after our country when she can't even look after her kids properly. I'm sorry, but a mother in her situation put in place as the VP just sends the wrong message to the American public. Palin can't wait to tie Obama to this radical or that "terrorist" or whoever, but while she may not be a member of the Alaskan party her husband belonged to, sleeping with the enemy just doesn't send good messages either.
Enough on Palin
The bailout package that just recently passed is a big sore spot for me. I saw on the internet the other day, a picture of a man carrying a sign that read "pennies for the people, billions for the banks". I feel this is more truth then anybody on Capitol Hill will admit to. As for what caused the problems, this is where it really gets silly to me. Everytime something goes wrong the Republicans can find a way to blame Clinton. Somehow they look and don't see the deregulation that Regan started in 1980. Regan, GHW Bush, and their allies made life misserable for people like me. Every time a Republican cries tax cut, I'm spending more out of my pocket. It cost me $200 to put my kid in one semester of marching band in the 9th grade. I work with a woman who's teenage girl is a cheerleader. For her, that little treat cost her $600. I had $400 in savings 2 weeks ago. Its gone just paying the dentist and my kids tutor. Who do I turn to when my bills outlast the money that comes in for the month.
The Repbulican crowd in this country talks about how Gorlick and her Democrat friends ran Fanny or Freddy and caused all this. BULLSHIT. It wasn't the Democrats who said give out liar's loans. It wasn't the democrats that made mortgage money available to instutions that had no expertise in mortgage lending. The idea that you have a segment of society earning 8 to 9 figures a year from this mess and another (far far larger) segment struggling with the day to day expences of living is just criminal.
While Al Gore is a favorite to be made fun of, I believe he is correct about his call for civil disobedience. I'm not running out and starting a riot, but lets look at where we are today in this country as far as justice is concerned. Nifong got off with only a token day in jail for all the trouble he caused. We have the Durham PD rivialed by the Hillsborough County Sheriff''s Office (Baby Sabrina Aisenberg) for being able to manufacture evidence quickly. How many Crystal Mangums do we have to watch lie and profit before we start calling for justice. How many innocent men and women have to go to jail and be proven innocent 3,5,maybe even 20 years after the fact before we start investigating DA's. My brother is a lawyer. He is the first one to giggle when I talk about the DA's duty to the truth and not convictions. It was a nice dog and pony show to put Bernie Ebbers in jail and give him people to talk to like Kozlowski of TYCO or Skilling of ENRON. I believe there should have been more. Will there be an investigation into the WaMu's and other instutions that failed followed by prison for the people who ran our financial sector into the ground. I hope so but it will be at best, another dog and pony show.
More later
I have never been accepting of the Hollywood stars that don't need a husband to have a baby. This is wrong. I understand that accidents happen, but in this day and age, the number should be very small. The idea we are sending a just-approaching-middle-age grandmother of an illigitimate kid to Washington just shuts me down. She wants the world to know that she is ready to look after our country when she can't even look after her kids properly. I'm sorry, but a mother in her situation put in place as the VP just sends the wrong message to the American public. Palin can't wait to tie Obama to this radical or that "terrorist" or whoever, but while she may not be a member of the Alaskan party her husband belonged to, sleeping with the enemy just doesn't send good messages either.
Enough on Palin
The bailout package that just recently passed is a big sore spot for me. I saw on the internet the other day, a picture of a man carrying a sign that read "pennies for the people, billions for the banks". I feel this is more truth then anybody on Capitol Hill will admit to. As for what caused the problems, this is where it really gets silly to me. Everytime something goes wrong the Republicans can find a way to blame Clinton. Somehow they look and don't see the deregulation that Regan started in 1980. Regan, GHW Bush, and their allies made life misserable for people like me. Every time a Republican cries tax cut, I'm spending more out of my pocket. It cost me $200 to put my kid in one semester of marching band in the 9th grade. I work with a woman who's teenage girl is a cheerleader. For her, that little treat cost her $600. I had $400 in savings 2 weeks ago. Its gone just paying the dentist and my kids tutor. Who do I turn to when my bills outlast the money that comes in for the month.
The Repbulican crowd in this country talks about how Gorlick and her Democrat friends ran Fanny or Freddy and caused all this. BULLSHIT. It wasn't the Democrats who said give out liar's loans. It wasn't the democrats that made mortgage money available to instutions that had no expertise in mortgage lending. The idea that you have a segment of society earning 8 to 9 figures a year from this mess and another (far far larger) segment struggling with the day to day expences of living is just criminal.
While Al Gore is a favorite to be made fun of, I believe he is correct about his call for civil disobedience. I'm not running out and starting a riot, but lets look at where we are today in this country as far as justice is concerned. Nifong got off with only a token day in jail for all the trouble he caused. We have the Durham PD rivialed by the Hillsborough County Sheriff''s Office (Baby Sabrina Aisenberg) for being able to manufacture evidence quickly. How many Crystal Mangums do we have to watch lie and profit before we start calling for justice. How many innocent men and women have to go to jail and be proven innocent 3,5,maybe even 20 years after the fact before we start investigating DA's. My brother is a lawyer. He is the first one to giggle when I talk about the DA's duty to the truth and not convictions. It was a nice dog and pony show to put Bernie Ebbers in jail and give him people to talk to like Kozlowski of TYCO or Skilling of ENRON. I believe there should have been more. Will there be an investigation into the WaMu's and other instutions that failed followed by prison for the people who ran our financial sector into the ground. I hope so but it will be at best, another dog and pony show.
More later
Sunday, April 1, 2007
"Left Wing / Right Wing" Wingnuts All
I've been reading the Duke related blogs for several months now and I am absolutely astonished at the "left wing / right wing" crap that I've been reading. The news media (print and televised) aren't a bunch of left wing shills. Quite frankly after watching BOR, gotta love it, thats Bill O'Reilly to folks like you and me, he has become such a raving lunatic cheerleader for the current president, that I want to throw up.
Nobody seems to remember a word that we used "back in the day". The word is radical. It means to go overboard, go to extremes, go to the outer limits. The media isn't radical left, and I'm not sure its radical right. The media has become a source for making news, not reporting it. When your new article starts out that...The New York Times is reporting........ or The Washington Post is reporting.....or The LA Times has confirmed....etc, there is a problem in your news organization. Quite frankly, if I read that "TMZ has confirmed/is reporting..." whatever, I'm going to start going to the horses mouth directly, and not reading it 3rd hand from someone who told me they got it from, who got it from. I should thank men like Dr. William Anderson of lewrockwell.com or Dr. KC Johnson of Durham In Wonderland for helping me get back on track with my reading.
What I'm seeing is not media biased toward this side or that, I'm seeing media that can make a big enough spectacle that it will sell. Based on what I'm reading in the NY Times or on CNN or where ever, the mass media takes whatever track will get you aroused enough to click on the story and trip their counters so they can sell ad space. This is not leftist, this is not rightist, its amoral fertilizer.
I get so upset when people look at a group like the Dixie Chicks and say things like they represent the lowest 5% of the population that get their news in 5 minutes at the top of the hour. Why, because I don't agree with them, President Bush is a disaster in office. He has not been a friend to the working man. He has given Cheney's buddies at Haliburton and Assoc. 27 billion of our money in "no bid" contracts and now they are moving to the UAE. 6 or 7 million new people now qualify for overtime according to his new rules......11 million lost it and those 11 million are the ones at Wal Mart and K Mart and elsewhere who didn't have it to loose to begin with. The press has been cheering him like dutiful little girls at a football game. Fox is the worst. The name callers are the ones calling "leftist" or "leftist agenda's" or whatever.
Nancy Grace is not leftist. She is a wingnut who will walk past evidence to sell her show. She is on a crusade to make cash and to hell with anybody who gets in her way. Anybody includes the mother of that missing boy she prosecuted....I mean interviewed.
Lest this be perceived as a rant against Nancy, BSNBC and FOX both had the round table discussions about Nancy like they were above any such thing.
I truly am disturbed by the state of the media these days.
Nobody seems to remember a word that we used "back in the day". The word is radical. It means to go overboard, go to extremes, go to the outer limits. The media isn't radical left, and I'm not sure its radical right. The media has become a source for making news, not reporting it. When your new article starts out that...The New York Times is reporting........ or The Washington Post is reporting.....or The LA Times has confirmed....etc, there is a problem in your news organization. Quite frankly, if I read that "TMZ has confirmed/is reporting..." whatever, I'm going to start going to the horses mouth directly, and not reading it 3rd hand from someone who told me they got it from, who got it from. I should thank men like Dr. William Anderson of lewrockwell.com or Dr. KC Johnson of Durham In Wonderland for helping me get back on track with my reading.
What I'm seeing is not media biased toward this side or that, I'm seeing media that can make a big enough spectacle that it will sell. Based on what I'm reading in the NY Times or on CNN or where ever, the mass media takes whatever track will get you aroused enough to click on the story and trip their counters so they can sell ad space. This is not leftist, this is not rightist, its amoral fertilizer.
I get so upset when people look at a group like the Dixie Chicks and say things like they represent the lowest 5% of the population that get their news in 5 minutes at the top of the hour. Why, because I don't agree with them, President Bush is a disaster in office. He has not been a friend to the working man. He has given Cheney's buddies at Haliburton and Assoc. 27 billion of our money in "no bid" contracts and now they are moving to the UAE. 6 or 7 million new people now qualify for overtime according to his new rules......11 million lost it and those 11 million are the ones at Wal Mart and K Mart and elsewhere who didn't have it to loose to begin with. The press has been cheering him like dutiful little girls at a football game. Fox is the worst. The name callers are the ones calling "leftist" or "leftist agenda's" or whatever.
Nancy Grace is not leftist. She is a wingnut who will walk past evidence to sell her show. She is on a crusade to make cash and to hell with anybody who gets in her way. Anybody includes the mother of that missing boy she prosecuted....I mean interviewed.
Lest this be perceived as a rant against Nancy, BSNBC and FOX both had the round table discussions about Nancy like they were above any such thing.
I truly am disturbed by the state of the media these days.
Thursday, March 29, 2007
Its Getting Old Already
Dear Atorney General Cooper
My guess is that you are trying to figure out how to get out of this without further damage to the democratic party. It ain't happening. What you need to do is end it quickly and let the healing begin. I probably wouldn't be writing this except the camel's back broke today reading the blogs. 7 of the best years of my life were spent in Charlotte and Salisbury. What broke the camel's back was a line I saw in the comments of a blog. "The Banana Republic of North Criminila."
You have had in excess of 70 days to review 1850 pages of documents. Thats less then 27 pages a day and dropping as you prolong this nonsense. Given 2 hours for reading, and 6 for data sorting, I'm thinking that you should have had this figured out by now. I realize that this doesn't include Interview time and photo op time, but it all averages out.
There is no way that you are going to get the public to take that spoonful of sugar to make this medicine go down. I've been a lifelong card carrying democrat for over 30 years and I assure you that under the current circumstances neither you nor Governor Easley would get my vote and I've always voted along party lines. I grew up believing that the democrats are the peoples party. History has told me I'm right. This is the exception to the rule.
Enough is enough already. What more do we need to wait for. If you do have any evidence that the public isn't aware of, then share it with defense council and lets get this show on the road. If not, then let the 3 innocent men move on. My father had an expression. To phrase it politely, it states "Poop or get out of the bathroom". I believe it applies here.
Sincerely
My guess is that you are trying to figure out how to get out of this without further damage to the democratic party. It ain't happening. What you need to do is end it quickly and let the healing begin. I probably wouldn't be writing this except the camel's back broke today reading the blogs. 7 of the best years of my life were spent in Charlotte and Salisbury. What broke the camel's back was a line I saw in the comments of a blog. "The Banana Republic of North Criminila."
You have had in excess of 70 days to review 1850 pages of documents. Thats less then 27 pages a day and dropping as you prolong this nonsense. Given 2 hours for reading, and 6 for data sorting, I'm thinking that you should have had this figured out by now. I realize that this doesn't include Interview time and photo op time, but it all averages out.
There is no way that you are going to get the public to take that spoonful of sugar to make this medicine go down. I've been a lifelong card carrying democrat for over 30 years and I assure you that under the current circumstances neither you nor Governor Easley would get my vote and I've always voted along party lines. I grew up believing that the democrats are the peoples party. History has told me I'm right. This is the exception to the rule.
Enough is enough already. What more do we need to wait for. If you do have any evidence that the public isn't aware of, then share it with defense council and lets get this show on the road. If not, then let the 3 innocent men move on. My father had an expression. To phrase it politely, it states "Poop or get out of the bathroom". I believe it applies here.
Sincerely
Saturday, March 17, 2007
Higher Education
I don’t really care what happens to Duke University, as I’ve never been a member of the faculty or staff nor an alumnus. I am sure the alumni care a great deal. This rant has less to do with Duke itself then with the bigger broader picture of what I see in their teaching staff. This is not limited to Dukes teaching staff as Peggy Reeves Sanday from Penn State and her, of late, biggest cheerleader, Dr. A.G. Rud from Perdue are guilty of the same thinking patterns as the 88 of Duke University.
There seems to be a great deal of friction between those academics who support Dr. KC Johnson and those who support the 88. Dr. Johnson, in his Durham in Wonderland blog looks at facts as pretty much black and white. Sanday, Rud, and most if not all of the 88 see facts as, to quote Dr. Rud, “open for discussion.” Where this comes into play is that the 88, Rud, Sanday, and others still see the disaster in Durham as a good example of the race, culture, privilege war.
Let’s look at the 88 and a quote from Dr. Baker. When asked if he or the rest of the 88 regretted the original ad now referred to as the listening ad, Dr Baker Responded
“We had a long discussion about what the word ‘regret’ means, and philosophy professors weighed in and we had detailed discussions in terms of the epistemology of specific words,” says Baker. “If you talk to 80 different college professors, you’ll have 80 different opinions.”
The very idea that the dictionary wouldn’t due for this, tells me not only that the above “open for discussion” concept, applies to everything in their lives, but that they are living in a 60’s hippie commune fantasy world where everything must be discussed. They are not willing to speak for themselves and hide behind the commune (group) walls they have created. The problem here is that most of the rest of the world sees facts as Dr. Johnson does. They see the word regret as the rest of us do. Had they had a consensus meeting and agreed that the definition of regret meant this or that, I doubt an apology statement would have been issued because nobody would have known what THEIR definition of regret meant. Perhaps worse, they might have issued one and been laughed at because of their obscure and philosophical definition.
On the subject of Dr. Rud, I read his blog and all I can think is that this man is easily impressed with his own hot air. Here are two quotes on evidence and its status as open for discussion:
“(using quotes I am)….. merely emphasizing that I see facts as conditional and open for discussion”
“I also use quotes to indicate my concern that these so-called "facts" be arrogated by one particular viewpoint, with what appears to me to be its attendant literalism and epistemological imperialism.”
And as best as I can translate with my Greek to English dictionary, he means this:
I also use quotes to indicate my concern that these so-called “facts” are claimed only by one particular viewpoint, with what appears to me to be its associated rigid adherence to that viewpoint and explicit imposition of power based only on those facts and viewpoint.
The first fallacy in his argument is that facts are open to discussion. They are not. They are however open to interpretation. There is a difference. For example, we find a dead body with a disfigured head and a bloody rock 3 feet from the body. Fact, the body is dead. Fact, the rock is bloody. Fact, the rock is in close proximity to the body. Discuss that! On the concept of interpretation, does the rock fit the disfigurement of the head? Is the blood type the same as that found on the dead body? Is the proximity of the rock to the body relevant to the fact that the body is dead? In short, was this a murder?
Lets apply this to the scandal, shall we. First, what facts do we have? We have a party attended by some of the lacrosse team. We have a party where drinking was involved. We have a party with entertainment (strippers). We have an accusation of rape and finally we have the ever-popular racial epithets.
If you listen to the 88 and company, they would have you believe that racially biased elitist men threw a party to get drunk and rape a stripper. Male bonding, as they like to call it. How do they come to this conclusion? They drag up a history of slave owners “having their way” with black slave women per Dr. Chafe. (Dr. Chafe, is this the explanation you would give to give to Heidi Klum’s kids?) They rely almost entirely on questionably anonymous quotes that in some cases are so carefully constructed that they sound more like a 50-year-old professor then a 20-year-old coed. They take individual facts and use them out of any context to support these ideas. The interpretation of the facts by the 88 and company would have you believe that this “girl who cried wolf” story is a fact that fits their cause. There in lies the crux of the feud. They see the story of an increasingly discredited storyteller as the backdrop for their cause. Then they claim the story as fact.
The story as fact is another fallacy. In proper research, you find an incident that actually happened and use its facts. You don’t find a story and use it. Sure, the men hired strippers, sure the men drank, BUT WHERE IS THE RAPE? They may be able to claim a group think mentality or a mob mentality, based on facts, but if they look at their own actions they are just as guilty. They would have you believe that the party and the drinking is an example of white male privilege. Tell that to the students at the strike parties after a show on campus. Tell that to the African American frat where the last alleged rape occurred. They would have you believe that a racial epithet is racism. Not to sound childish, but Kim started it, the SOLE offender to this was just following suit. If I took a story to my psychology professor and said, “Here, this is an example of my claim.” he would have said that it exists only in my mind and maybe in the mind of the author.
On the subject of racial epithets, the group claims racism. I don’t see it. First and foremost, the group keeps using the word epithets, the plural. The only proof of epithets is a single exchange between Kim Roberts and one of the players. Kim Roberts according to witnesses started the exchange. Far too many of the individuals who use them at a time like that are guilty of venting stupidity with their anger. As a youth, I was guilty of using the N word in anger. Not because I am racist, but because my vocabulary was insufficient to defend myself otherwise. I never actually heard the word till I was 10 years old or so. Instead of requiring a diversity course for all students, they might try an English class with a focus on vocabulary.
As this paper is into its 3rd page, it dawns on me that it could become a book. A book I would say, I have no time to write and others are more qualified to write. To sum up the above, the 88 have taken facts out of context and claimed them as support for a cause. They appear to manufacture facts as they need (I wonder any of them taught Nifong), and they refuse to see the other side as they want others to see theirs. This scares me out of my shoes. The idea that more then 10 percent of a college faculty think along these lines is bad enough, but to find it at one of the most prestigious schools in the U.S. should be criminal.
There seems to be a great deal of friction between those academics who support Dr. KC Johnson and those who support the 88. Dr. Johnson, in his Durham in Wonderland blog looks at facts as pretty much black and white. Sanday, Rud, and most if not all of the 88 see facts as, to quote Dr. Rud, “open for discussion.” Where this comes into play is that the 88, Rud, Sanday, and others still see the disaster in Durham as a good example of the race, culture, privilege war.
Let’s look at the 88 and a quote from Dr. Baker. When asked if he or the rest of the 88 regretted the original ad now referred to as the listening ad, Dr Baker Responded
“We had a long discussion about what the word ‘regret’ means, and philosophy professors weighed in and we had detailed discussions in terms of the epistemology of specific words,” says Baker. “If you talk to 80 different college professors, you’ll have 80 different opinions.”
The very idea that the dictionary wouldn’t due for this, tells me not only that the above “open for discussion” concept, applies to everything in their lives, but that they are living in a 60’s hippie commune fantasy world where everything must be discussed. They are not willing to speak for themselves and hide behind the commune (group) walls they have created. The problem here is that most of the rest of the world sees facts as Dr. Johnson does. They see the word regret as the rest of us do. Had they had a consensus meeting and agreed that the definition of regret meant this or that, I doubt an apology statement would have been issued because nobody would have known what THEIR definition of regret meant. Perhaps worse, they might have issued one and been laughed at because of their obscure and philosophical definition.
On the subject of Dr. Rud, I read his blog and all I can think is that this man is easily impressed with his own hot air. Here are two quotes on evidence and its status as open for discussion:
“(using quotes I am)….. merely emphasizing that I see facts as conditional and open for discussion”
“I also use quotes to indicate my concern that these so-called "facts" be arrogated by one particular viewpoint, with what appears to me to be its attendant literalism and epistemological imperialism.”
And as best as I can translate with my Greek to English dictionary, he means this:
I also use quotes to indicate my concern that these so-called “facts” are claimed only by one particular viewpoint, with what appears to me to be its associated rigid adherence to that viewpoint and explicit imposition of power based only on those facts and viewpoint.
The first fallacy in his argument is that facts are open to discussion. They are not. They are however open to interpretation. There is a difference. For example, we find a dead body with a disfigured head and a bloody rock 3 feet from the body. Fact, the body is dead. Fact, the rock is bloody. Fact, the rock is in close proximity to the body. Discuss that! On the concept of interpretation, does the rock fit the disfigurement of the head? Is the blood type the same as that found on the dead body? Is the proximity of the rock to the body relevant to the fact that the body is dead? In short, was this a murder?
Lets apply this to the scandal, shall we. First, what facts do we have? We have a party attended by some of the lacrosse team. We have a party where drinking was involved. We have a party with entertainment (strippers). We have an accusation of rape and finally we have the ever-popular racial epithets.
If you listen to the 88 and company, they would have you believe that racially biased elitist men threw a party to get drunk and rape a stripper. Male bonding, as they like to call it. How do they come to this conclusion? They drag up a history of slave owners “having their way” with black slave women per Dr. Chafe. (Dr. Chafe, is this the explanation you would give to give to Heidi Klum’s kids?) They rely almost entirely on questionably anonymous quotes that in some cases are so carefully constructed that they sound more like a 50-year-old professor then a 20-year-old coed. They take individual facts and use them out of any context to support these ideas. The interpretation of the facts by the 88 and company would have you believe that this “girl who cried wolf” story is a fact that fits their cause. There in lies the crux of the feud. They see the story of an increasingly discredited storyteller as the backdrop for their cause. Then they claim the story as fact.
The story as fact is another fallacy. In proper research, you find an incident that actually happened and use its facts. You don’t find a story and use it. Sure, the men hired strippers, sure the men drank, BUT WHERE IS THE RAPE? They may be able to claim a group think mentality or a mob mentality, based on facts, but if they look at their own actions they are just as guilty. They would have you believe that the party and the drinking is an example of white male privilege. Tell that to the students at the strike parties after a show on campus. Tell that to the African American frat where the last alleged rape occurred. They would have you believe that a racial epithet is racism. Not to sound childish, but Kim started it, the SOLE offender to this was just following suit. If I took a story to my psychology professor and said, “Here, this is an example of my claim.” he would have said that it exists only in my mind and maybe in the mind of the author.
On the subject of racial epithets, the group claims racism. I don’t see it. First and foremost, the group keeps using the word epithets, the plural. The only proof of epithets is a single exchange between Kim Roberts and one of the players. Kim Roberts according to witnesses started the exchange. Far too many of the individuals who use them at a time like that are guilty of venting stupidity with their anger. As a youth, I was guilty of using the N word in anger. Not because I am racist, but because my vocabulary was insufficient to defend myself otherwise. I never actually heard the word till I was 10 years old or so. Instead of requiring a diversity course for all students, they might try an English class with a focus on vocabulary.
As this paper is into its 3rd page, it dawns on me that it could become a book. A book I would say, I have no time to write and others are more qualified to write. To sum up the above, the 88 have taken facts out of context and claimed them as support for a cause. They appear to manufacture facts as they need (I wonder any of them taught Nifong), and they refuse to see the other side as they want others to see theirs. This scares me out of my shoes. The idea that more then 10 percent of a college faculty think along these lines is bad enough, but to find it at one of the most prestigious schools in the U.S. should be criminal.
Thursday, March 15, 2007
An Open Letter To Duke University President Brodhead
Dear President Brodhead:
I am writing you in reference to the public disaster your school and surrounding community faced last year. I’m sure we both understand I am talking about what is now commonly known as the lacrosse rape scandal. Social or otherwise, I’m sure we both agree that this was a terrible disaster.
I read the blogs and I read the newspapers but these are not the reasons I’m writing. I am writing because of what this outsider sees happening to your school. I am a married father of 2 looking at my first tuition bill in about 5 years. While I’m not sure I’ll be able to afford your institution, I’m equally not sure that I would encourage my children to go. The disaster your community experienced last year could have been better survived with great strength and leadership at several levels. Sadly, this was not to be seen.
While you as an individual and president of the school cannot stop freedom of speech, you should have cautioned your faculty at all levels, both publicly and privately, that they are seen as representatives of your school. I do not mean just those individuals known now as the Group of 88, I am referring to the entire faculty. Those who openly support either side are going to upset somebody. This should have happened very early on. We, the national community have not seen strength or organization from Duke at the levels we should have. We did not see strength to stand up and protect those 3 individual students or the rest of the team while evidence was still being collected.
What we the outside, national community have seen is tremendous infighting between students and teachers, and amongst the faculty. This infighting, this disorganization is doing very serious damage to your school’s image. For schools at your level, image is a very great deal as I’m sure I don’t have to remind you. Further, this lack of organization has cost you a coach and who knows what, that we haven’t heard about.
I firmly believe that this situation is correctable. To correct it will take strength in the face of adversity. I believe several actions are long past due and still not too late to take. These actions will anger many I’m sure. The question I would pose is simply this: Does the current Duke administration have that strength?
First, The longer Collin, Reade, and David are in the news, the longer Duke is known for a scandal. I believe you should exercise whatever resources you have to show Attorney General Cooper and Governor Easley your support for those men. This scandal is still going and needs to end.
Second, the faculty, and I mean the entire faculty, must show unity in the face of this disaster. This unity will take a great negotiator. It will also show organization. It has been a year since this started. We, the national community, still haven’t seen organization from Duke.
The publicity that the 88 professors are garnering needs to be handled through one source. Whether that source is one of the faculty directly such as Dr Lubiano or Dr. Chafe, or an outside agency, one source is needed. This will also show organization and take a great negotiator. It will also show the tolerance those 88 professors were looking for.
Finally, and this is very telling to me, is the alumni. I am aware of Friends of Duke University, which was started by an alumnus. It should tell you something when the alumni are talking and it’s not in agreement with the loudest voices currently on the campus. There are no Friends of Duke University, no alumni, coming forward to say the group is correct. What do they know that the 88 don’t? Ask them.
In conclusion, I’d like to thank you for the time you invested in reading this letter. I understand you receive many demands in your daily duties at Duke, most of them being time. I have pointed out only what I see as limits on the future of Duke and a long history of high educational standards. I pray that you, the university and the surrounding community affected by this, find peace.
Sincerely
I am writing you in reference to the public disaster your school and surrounding community faced last year. I’m sure we both understand I am talking about what is now commonly known as the lacrosse rape scandal. Social or otherwise, I’m sure we both agree that this was a terrible disaster.
I read the blogs and I read the newspapers but these are not the reasons I’m writing. I am writing because of what this outsider sees happening to your school. I am a married father of 2 looking at my first tuition bill in about 5 years. While I’m not sure I’ll be able to afford your institution, I’m equally not sure that I would encourage my children to go. The disaster your community experienced last year could have been better survived with great strength and leadership at several levels. Sadly, this was not to be seen.
While you as an individual and president of the school cannot stop freedom of speech, you should have cautioned your faculty at all levels, both publicly and privately, that they are seen as representatives of your school. I do not mean just those individuals known now as the Group of 88, I am referring to the entire faculty. Those who openly support either side are going to upset somebody. This should have happened very early on. We, the national community have not seen strength or organization from Duke at the levels we should have. We did not see strength to stand up and protect those 3 individual students or the rest of the team while evidence was still being collected.
What we the outside, national community have seen is tremendous infighting between students and teachers, and amongst the faculty. This infighting, this disorganization is doing very serious damage to your school’s image. For schools at your level, image is a very great deal as I’m sure I don’t have to remind you. Further, this lack of organization has cost you a coach and who knows what, that we haven’t heard about.
I firmly believe that this situation is correctable. To correct it will take strength in the face of adversity. I believe several actions are long past due and still not too late to take. These actions will anger many I’m sure. The question I would pose is simply this: Does the current Duke administration have that strength?
First, The longer Collin, Reade, and David are in the news, the longer Duke is known for a scandal. I believe you should exercise whatever resources you have to show Attorney General Cooper and Governor Easley your support for those men. This scandal is still going and needs to end.
Second, the faculty, and I mean the entire faculty, must show unity in the face of this disaster. This unity will take a great negotiator. It will also show organization. It has been a year since this started. We, the national community, still haven’t seen organization from Duke.
The publicity that the 88 professors are garnering needs to be handled through one source. Whether that source is one of the faculty directly such as Dr Lubiano or Dr. Chafe, or an outside agency, one source is needed. This will also show organization and take a great negotiator. It will also show the tolerance those 88 professors were looking for.
Finally, and this is very telling to me, is the alumni. I am aware of Friends of Duke University, which was started by an alumnus. It should tell you something when the alumni are talking and it’s not in agreement with the loudest voices currently on the campus. There are no Friends of Duke University, no alumni, coming forward to say the group is correct. What do they know that the 88 don’t? Ask them.
In conclusion, I’d like to thank you for the time you invested in reading this letter. I understand you receive many demands in your daily duties at Duke, most of them being time. I have pointed out only what I see as limits on the future of Duke and a long history of high educational standards. I pray that you, the university and the surrounding community affected by this, find peace.
Sincerely
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)